Reviews
The Disaster Artist
2017
.
R
.
1h 44m
James Franco’s The Disaster Artist is this generation’s answer to Tim Burton’s Ed Wood: A biopic about a passionate but talentless filmmaker pouring his heart and soul into what many would ultimately consider one of the worst movies ever made. The filmmaker is Tommy Wiseau, and the film is The Room – what I described in my zero-star review, interestingly enough, as “incompetent at a level not seen since the films of Ed Wood.” I went on to describe it as “so excruciatingly awful on every conceivable level that its only hope of being remembered is to find a cult audience with very low standards.” Lo and behold, it has found a cult audience; like The Rocky Horror Picture Show, midnight screenings are regularly held, and audiences in costume come prepared with props and lines to shout back at the screen.
The Disaster Artist and Ed Wood are similar in that they both relied on talented performers who, in reenacting actual scenes from awful movies, are called upon to intentionally act badly. When you really do know how to act, this is incredibly difficult to pull off. In both cases, but specifically in the case of The Disaster Artist, the actors make it seem so effortless. Topping that list is Franco, who cast himself as Wiseau. This goes beyond the reenactment scenes; physically, vocally, and emotionally, he captures Wiseau so thoroughly that it’s more of an embodiment than a mere performance. The irony of that isn’t lost on me.
Much like Ed Wood, The Disaster Artist views its subject with a mixture of sympathy and pity – sympathy because Wiseau was an artist who cared deeply about his work, pity because he was either blind to or unmindful of his obvious lack of talent. At no point does Franco try to portray him as a misunderstood genius, a budding James Dean (an actor Franco portrayed, incidentally). He does, however, show a certain admiration for Wiseau’s complete willingness to put himself out there for the love of acting and the art of filmmaking. He had no idea what he was doing, and he certainly looked like a fool doing it, but the simple fact is that he went out there and actually did it. How many “aspiring filmmakers” can say the same thing?
Franco takes great delight in depicting Wiseau’s eccentric and mysterious nature. He always speaks as if drunk or stoned. His foreign accent is unplaceable, although he sticks to the story that he’s from New Orleans. No one knows how old he is, and it’s anyone’s guess how he has the money for not just two apartments – one in San Francisco, one in Los Angeles – but also the production of The Room. He goes into the project knowing nothing about the technical side of filmmaking yet unwavering in his belief that every decision he makes about lighting, camera placement, etc. is correct. Sometimes, this comes off as confidence. Other times, it’s pure arrogance. He acts on whims, never thinking of what could happen, never stopping to reflect on what actually did happen.
The film’s emotional core is the relationship between Wiseau and Greg Sestero (Dave Franco), who moved with Wiseau from San Francisco to Los Angeles to pursue acting, ended up playing Mark in The Room, and whose nonfiction book with Tom Bissell served as the basis for The Disaster Artist. Given what we see, it’s presumed that, until Sestero entered his life, Wiseau used his strangeness as a defense mechanism against the rest of the world. It would also seem he considered Sestero his first true friend. Did Sestero feel the same way? Certainly he was amused by Wiseau and fascinated by his fearlessness. But he also becomes painfully aware of Wiseau’s jealousy and possessiveness, most strikingly when Wiseau forces him to choose between finishing The Room and the chance to appear on an episode of Malcolm in the Middle, the latter being an obviously good stepping stone towards an acting career.
As in Ed Wood, in which the making of Plan 9 from Outer Space was an entertaining highlight, the making of The Room provides The Disaster Artist with its biggest laughs. Everyone behind the scenes, especially the script supervisor (Seth Rogen), knows their boss is helming a catastrophe, and they can only stare in disbelief as each day of shooting unfolds. It was especially fun seeing Ari Graynor, Josh Hutcherson, Jacki Weaver, and Zac Efron portray actors from The Room, and it goes back to what I said earlier about intentional bad acting. Right before the end credits, we’re shown side-by-side comparisons, clips from The Room on the left and Franco’s reenactments on the right; the fact that Franco’s actors were able to mimic their Room counterparts almost exactly is a testament not just to genuine acting chops, but also to those who take the craft seriously, who wholeheartedly work at it.
